Games like Paper Mario: Time Strewn Star

Mario's Timeless Picross

Super Luigi Dreams 2: Tale of the Dream Stone

Super Paper Bowser World

Super Mario Legend

Super Mario Legend is a 2D Mario fangame, playing similarly to the classic Mario platformers, but also adding unique new concepts to the formula, and containing story progression similar to the Paper Mario or Mario & Luigi series.

Super Mario Bratarsi

Super Mario Bratarsi is Jaklub's Super Mario fangame, which joins gameplay of Super Mario 2, 3 and World and mix it with various Super Mario elements.

Project Superstar

Super EarthBound

An unofficial crossover game that combines the platforming of Mario with the characters of EarthBound.